Friday, 28 June 2013

Afghansty

I've just finished Afghansty by Sir Roderick Braithwaite. The parallels between what the Soviets tried to do, and what ISAF is trying to do, are striking.



Like American and British forces, the Soviets lost no tactical engagements, and left with a compliant regime in place. Like the Soviets, we've been there for a decade, nominally at the request of the Government in Kabul. Like the Soviets, we're actually taking part (again) in a 300-year-old inter Pashtun civil war between Kabul and Kandahar/Quetta, for control of Afghanistan.

Like the Soviets, most of our kit is heading North when we leave.

If they've any sense, the Americans'll avoid the Friendship Bridge over the Amu Darya into Uzbekistan where the picture above was taken. Nevertheless There will be a picture of American troops and vehicles crossing the same border, over a bridge, somewhere. Whether Karzai and democracy survive in Afghanistan for 5 years or 500, that picture will be the legacy of a decade-long adventure, that the media narrative will decide was lost. Like the Soviets, that will not be entirely fair.



2 comments:

Anonymous said...

CAMERON SMELLS OF POO !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

-Jackfart

simon said...

your (again) link is broken i think, it directs me towards the blogger home page.

There was an error in this gadget